Fork me on GitHub
#clojure-europe
<
2022-12-14
>
reefersleep07:12:24

Good morning 🙂 We had another sprinkle of snow tonight, lovely.

javahippie08:12:55

Morning! We had a light sprinkle of rain at -2°C tonight, continuing into the morning. Happy to have survived the walk with our dog 😅

grav08:12:37

Morning!

RAMart08:12:19

Hi y'all! 👋

simongray08:12:31

good morning

robert-stuttaford08:12:21

hi! still just stupidly cold with a clear sky here

1
thomas09:12:24

Morning.... and same

lemontea15:12:35

same good, same good 👍

simongray13:12:07

Currently trying to convince my colleagues that, yes, it is possible to license newer versions of your software differently. They are convinced that it can’t be done if the new license contradicts the old one, while I’m trying to tell them that it doesn’t matter when you are the one who owns the copyright…

🙏 1
😆 1
reefersleep13:12:56

There must be some law text supporting your claim

simongray13:12:26

I think a basic Google search would lead to that

simongray13:12:01

The main issue is convincing them that this Jørgen guy probably isn’t the expert he purports to be after they’ve spent a decade believing so.

mccraigmccraig13:12:03

presumably they are getting confused by the difference between "retrospectively changing the license on already out-there releases" and "changing the license for future releases" ?

simongray13:12:13

Exactly. Maybe I should email them a link to the official documentation about Clojure’s approach to identity and state :rolling_on_the_floor_laughing:

mccraigmccraig13:12:21

with the first being expressly forbidden by some (i looked at MIT, and it's forbidden there) oss licenses, and the second being absolutely fine

simongray13:12:01

I’ve already sent them several emails explaining that actually we aren’t modifying the licence, just relicensing for new users

simongray13:12:38

To them the software is exactly one entity, not several releases with separate licences. It’s very hard to get through to them about this.

mccraigmccraig13:12:57

ah, you need an IAAL person to override their IANAL issues

simongray13:12:43

I have had to think about software licences since I was a teenager. I wish they would just trust me on this.

mccraigmccraig13:12:27

or alternatively, find someone called jørgen to offer up a revised opinion ? if they can't tell the difference between software versions, they might not be able to tell the difference between jørgens!

😁 5
thomas13:12:30

or let them talk to a lawyer... that will heal them.

grav14:12:12

Surprised no-one has yet suggested asking http://chat.openai.com

😂 1
simongray14:12:50

Now I just to prove that ChatGPT isn’t making shit up 😛

👍 1
💥 2
mccraigmccraig14:12:07

i don't think ChatGPT gave you a useful answer there @U4P4NREBY 😢

mccraigmccraig14:12:36

it doesn't talk about newer versions being allowed to have different license options from prior versions

thomas14:12:05

"Skærmbillede" what a fantastic word!!!

😁 1
simongray14:12:31

@U0524B4UW Perhaps this is better

mccraigmccraig14:12:54

bingo: now it's hitting the 💅 right on the 👦 !

thomas14:12:58

so picky these AI's

simongray14:12:31

To be fair, the first prompt was also a bit biased. BTW I actually just sent them the second skærmbillede 😛

😂 1
mccraigmccraig14:12:40

yep, agree - the first prompt was ambiguous and it responded well to one interpretation of the prompt

mccraigmccraig14:12:11

you must really be on tenterhooks waiting to find out whether they will believe chatGPT when they wouldn't believe you!

😁 1
simongray14:12:18

and TIL the word tenterhook

Jakub Holý (HolyJak)12:12:18

You could point out that some software is published under dual licenses, such as an open source and an incompatible commercial one. So I would argue you could even license old versions under a different license in addition to the old one. For new releases you could then use just the new one.

simongray13:12:47

But noooo noooo, someone called Jørgen apparently once told them that it can’t be done…!

simongray13:12:00

So they don’t believe me.

simongray13:12:10

(sorry for the rant)

thomas14:12:14

no worries.... that is what we are here for. To help and support each other with rants so that we all can keep a tiny bit of our sanity. :hugging_face:

❤️ 1
💯 1
orestis15:12:22

We now need a Jørgen emoji. And yes, I can type ø without copy-pasting 😄

😁 1
RAMart15:12:38

ö œ ø Ha! Me too!

orestis15:12:17

æ is the most annoying as it's not obvious at all 🙂

mccraigmccraig15:12:51

it's less æsthetically placed

lemontea15:12:01

you own a badass specialised keyboard or sth? (I really don’t know)

mccraigmccraig15:12:04

i'm on a vanilla UK macbook keyboard - i have alt-o=ø, alt-a=å and alt-'=æ by default ... there are others, but i don't use them, so i don't know them

👍 1
lemontea15:12:44

that’s some pwnage

lemontea15:12:30

unicode, i18l, and inclusiveness, that’s way to goooo

orestis15:12:19

I always thought that the funny-looking o, a etc are just accents, but they are actually their own letters.

orestis15:12:05

(Greek has accents that are generally stripped away for most NLP tasks)

simongray17:12:45

@U0524B4UW wait, why do you use Scandinavian letters? Are you secretly Scandinavian?

mccraigmccraig17:12:01

@U4P4NREBY i'm british, but lived in norway for a bit... my oldest son and my ex still do... i have a norsk personnummer, although i don't know what it is... so i have no idea what that makes me

simongray17:12:58

Fake Norwegian?

mccraigmccraig18:12:11

ha, my norsk is pretty rusty these days, so i'll be a poor-quality fake, bought in the pub on a drunken night out

simongray18:12:27

Good enough 😉

😂 1
lemontea15:12:26

morninggggg… hitting new low temperature over here (I think) (nothing compared to what’s in Europe though)

simongray17:12:46

Where are you located?

lemontea13:12:46

Hong Kong 😅

lemontea13:12:04

nvm the temperature is back up today…… for now

simongray17:12:19

Love Hong Kong!

💖 1
lemontea15:12:42

(the gggg is my body shaking lol)

genRaiy16:12:55

Good night

3
✔️ 1
❤️ 6
otfrom17:12:15

tentacles are going to come out of that and pull me in. You can't fool me again.

🦞 1
mccraigmccraig18:12:56

so you already escaped once @U0525KG62? or are you now a different @U0525KG62, dispatched to lure more victims ?

otfrom18:12:54

no change here, why do you ask?

mccraigmccraig18:12:58

oh, no big reason, maybe just wondering whether to go into hiding...

mccraigmccraig18:12:44

/me rushes to fridge to throw away last night's calamari

otfrom18:12:09

👁️ 👁️

mccraigmccraig18:12:54

nothing to see here ... 🙈