slack-help 2026-11-17

Is there a better way to keep track of a discussion? I have now encountered once or twice a situation where a thread went a bit viral and I was really intrigued by the different perspectives But since you can't react to individual messages if you're already in a thread, it's very easy to lose track of what message is a response to what other message and what the initial topic was. Am I holding slack wrong or is it just not 100% the right platform for a deep discussion?

The search feature has been pretty helpful for me but I do agree that especially for nested threads it can sometimes be easy to forget “where”/when exactly, part of a conversation took place.

I think slack is just not good at this once you’re already in a thread, all i could suggest is maybe reply with a new message in the channel which includes a link to the thread message so that another thread can start from there on that topic/subtopic

Yeah, we encourage threading here to allow a) for multiple conversations to happen at the same time (each in a thread) and b) so folks not involved in a given discussion aren’t swamped with main-channel posts they are not interested in. The downside is that Slack doesn’t have nested threading, so if a thread “forks”, there’s no good way to handle that. Forwarding a specific message from a thread back to the main channel in order to start a new conversation would probably work, but it would depend on good “thread discipline” which a lot of folks here haven’t always been too good about (which is also why this question even comes up).

From my perspective the habbit of using threads to keep the main channel has slowly emerged over the years (I don’t remember exactly when, but it was not always a thing!). People were sometimes correcting each other and some people were leading by example: “statement … details in 🧵”. I believe a better discipline for nested threads could happen if enough people introduce a working convention. I saw Stuart Halloway doing this here https://clojurians.slack.com/archives/C0B7Q4XRM1U/p1793107519295659

Yup, I think that’s a reasonable way to pull out a point from a thread and start a new discussion. Slack introduced threads as a feature in 2017. This community started in 2015. We started encouraging use of threads in mid-2017. I just searched the archives to find that. (we talk about threads a lot here but of course mostly mean JVM threads, so finding those first references was tedious!)

🙌 2

Almost a decade! 👀

Time flies when we’re having fun 🙂

➕ 1