emacs 2026-11-02

I'm working on the 2026 edition of the Clojure Survey. I'd love to get your help making sure the Emacs questions are up to date. 🧵

The attached image has the questions and answers from last year. You can see them by visiting "Page 4: Emacs" on the web at: https://www.surveymonkey.com/results/SM-q_2Bk9jFSywg5RRgxNruucNQ_3D_3D/

Are there any questions that need updated answers?

Are there any questions we should drop or add?

The point of these questions to understand how to improve the overall "feeling of the ecosystem", and I think one of the biggest unknowns is how the tooling is being used for data exploration (since Clojure is pure blackmagickfuckery for data) I personally would be curious to know how people are using Org-mode, its source blocks to deal with data, if they do that at all, and how Clojure is used there. Maybe that's already there in the survey, in some other section with questions about data manipulation, and I have an eerie feeling of déjà vu, like I already asked something similar last year. If that's the case, I apologise for the noise.

@hhausman @lee @ericdallo @bozhidar @jr0cket Thanks for your help last year too.

@ag We haven't asked anything directly about data exploration. If I recall, the data science folks have done some surveys about that.

There's also https://github.com/BuddhiLW/clojure-elisp with similar goals, but both of them have virtually zero traction. Unless the point is to advertise their existence, there's imo not much point of surveying about them. Most Emacs users haven't even heard of them.

@neumann - nice to see you. re: version numbers, Emacs 31.1 is in wide use iiuc.

1
1

Perhaps a question about CIDER 1.x vs 2.x --- my personal experience of tracking recent versions has been very positive.

Ah yes. Good point. Emacs 31 been out for a while now. I'm now using (unreleased) 32. The release cycle and pace have changed.

I think you've covered all the most interesting points in last year's survey. These are the main differences I usually see when I talk to other Emacsers, and what I'd be curious to know about someone's setup 😊

might be interesting to see what emacs folks use for data inspection, like portal, cider-inspect or other tools. Just to understand what integrates better with emacs

1

When you mention it, I'd actually be very curious to hear about that too! There's also https://github.com/clojure-emacs/sayid/ and the new cider-tap and *cider-trace* https://metaredux.com/posts/2026/07/28/sharpening-ciders-debugging-tools.html.

@neumann this might be a polemic question, but I think it really worth to add it, for people that code with AI, how much of that is inside Emacs or not? I think this is important because in the era of AI, there are people completing coding via AI where they left editors, but there are people using inside editors (like #C093426FPUG, gptel etc), I think that's good to understand whether people use Emacs as an editor or more just a wrapper/harness for AI coding as they are completely different things

👍 5

I agree. I myself have been wondering about the overall impact on editor and IDE usage, and how this usage has changed in the past year.

Perhaps having a separate page in the survey on the use of 'AI', so people who dont use these tools can easily skip those questions

LGTM @neumann! I am also interested in AI uptake and usage within IDEs (I'm personally not a user of AI in that way).

Yes, AI coding is a separate page of questions. I've started the discussion over in #C068E9L5M2Q. See this thread: https://clojurians.slack.com/archives/C068E9L5M2Q/p1793758212769079

I’m passing the baton to @alexmiller to push the survey over the finish line, but I’ll be supporting him.

Alex Miller (Clojure team) 2026-11-06T22:21:57.980809Z

I’ve updated the Emacs versions, the REPL packages (split into CIDER 1.x and 2.x). AI stuff will be handled separately. Other things mentioned (data inspectors, buffers, etc) I think are beyond the level of detail we want to cover here

2