Can't help you, but I'm interested too. I wasn't using fireplace yet when I last used shadow, but sooner or later I will do frontend stuff again and will run into exactly same problem.

shadow & fireplace worked at some point

they should still work really, but the :Piggieback command probably changed in recent version

s

yeah, that is weird 🙂 I was watching that conversation very confused

I guess I can spin up a new shadow project and check how it goes

yeah, it all worked with cider-nrepl a few months ago. Here is the new piggieback command you would need: https://github.com/thheller/shadow-cljs/issues/62 It's :Piggieback (shadow.cljs.devtools.api/nrepl-select :app) in my particular case.

ah, you're already on that eh 🙂

tpope tracked that one down for me. I would have never found that sucker

I'm a bit confused, I downloaded https://github.com/minimal-xyz/minimal-shadow-cljs-browser/blob/master/shadow-cljs.edn and connected, and piggieback worked fine, I got a js/alert working

what's broken? 😄

lol! of course. let me try this out.

so you have no dependencies in there? I don't get it.

how weird is that! So yeah the repl's connect fine without the dependencies at all. Not sure how that worked because I thought I was just told two weeks ago that fireplace requires cider-nrepl.

But are you saying you also have your clojure-vim/async-clj-omni working for autocompletion and docs and such? @U09LZR36F

because how does that work without cider/cider-nrepl? I'm so confused

no, I added cider/cider-nrepl to the deps, and it still worked

what the frick!?

I didn't test completion, but I assume it would work

When I add [cider/cider-nrepl "0.21.1"] to my dependencies and try to connect I get a long stacktrace error that starts with this:

[2019-08-06 16:50:41 - SEVERE] Unhandled REPL handler exception processing message {:id 398aa901-f222-47a9-ac21-67eb35075490, :op classpath}
java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: No implementation of method: :send of protocol: #'nrepl.transport/Transport found for class: clojure.tools.nrepl.transport.FnTransport

that explains some of the mystery though. I never needed that nrepl dependency or piggieback apparently. I was just having an issue with this cider-nrepl dependency the whole time.

https://pastebin.com/cgH7V1b4 Do you happen to notice anything here? This is git cloned from the tutorial I'm using but just replacing proto repl (he uses Atom) with cider

Nothing jumps out :thinking_face:

no worries. I'm failing to see exactly how this: https://github.com/jacekschae/learn-reagent-course-files/tree/master/giggin differs from your example repository but I'm missing something. I can complete the tutorial without cider I guess I just don't know what I'll do in the future.

I just tried adding cider-nrepl to a shadow-cljs project and it's also blowing up in weird ways

oh thank goodness. lol. My default is that I'm doing something horribly inept but thankfully someone competent has confirmed

i mean i'm competent with fireplace but i wouldn't call myself competent with shadow-cljs ¯\(ツ)/¯

last time I wrangled you into this I had asked the shadow-cljs folks about the "blowing up" and that's when theller recommended the nrepl thing instead. But the cider guys say that's not right. But theller doesn't use cider so it's a fun little back and forth in which I can provide nothing to help

let me go ask the cider guys again and see if they know what's up.

I just found a bug on automatic piggiebacking that may or may not have been affecting you

try the latest

updated (I saw the fix in the commit list of updates) and still getting the error and inability to connect with clj before I get to the piggieback stage though.

is :CljEval 1 failing?

are you running shadow-cljs watch app or what?

oh wait, hold on.

sort of. I run npm run dev and that starts shadow-cljs watch app

λ ~/projects/learn-reagent-course-files/giggin : npm run dev

> [email protected] dev /home/chaselambert/projects/learn-reagent-course-files/giggin
> shadow-cljs watch app

shadow-cljs - config: /home/chaselambert/projects/learn-reagent-course-files/giggin/shadow-cljs.edn  cli version: 2.3.30  node: v12.6.0

running that :CljEval 1 command just locks up my editor until I C-c out of it.

npm run dev should work

tested that on conduit if you're looking for another app to try

i'll try that one now

that one works!

so maybe it's one of the other dependencies or something? I'll have to compare the edn files

yeah that's where i'd start

sweet! I'll try and track that one down. unfortunately I have to run out right now. Thanks for all your help again!

I'll be back on in a couple of hours and I'll update if I solve it.

Maybe you need nrepl & cider? Just a suspicion

I think I've solved it fellas. I updated the shadow-cljs dependency in the package.json and I think everything is working fine now.

I really apologize if that's something that should have been super obvious to do and I've wasted all your time. At least it seemed a couple non related bugs were found, right???

haha 🙂

@U9J50BY4C Just curious, so old version of shadow was the cuplrit? What was the broken version?

The tutorial I am using had it at "2.3.30" but the current version is "2.8.43". I guess you set it in the package.json file though, not anywhere in the edn config.