Clojurians Log v2

Yes, the nvim-treesitter-nvim provides a series of https://github.com/PaterJason/nvim-treesitter-sexp?tab=readme-ov-file#configuration. I'll add some key mapping examples that use <leader>k to the practicalli config this evening, to help with discoverability.

@luciolucio Changes to the nvim-treesitter-sexp config in Practicalli Astronvim User Config have been pushed. I would be interested to know if the default key mappings from the plugin or the <leader>k mappings are the most useful.

Thanks, just updated and gave them a try. Let me play a little with both options for a few days and see what happens.

Love the examples, thanks for that! I migrated over to the new style config, and I tried to use the example nvim-treesitter-sexp config but I don't get a <localleader> k menu which is what I'd expect from the config.

Is that working for you? I made these changes in lua/plugins/clojure.lua but still no cigar. • Removed out the first line • Removed all other structural editing configs • Set enabled to true • Uncommented the keymaps key

I also disabled the community pack's parinfer through plugins/user.lua

I do see some paredit-like structural editing, but not sure where those are coming from

,@ Splice element
,O Promote element
,o Promote form

<( Slurp left
<) Barf right
>( Barf left
>) Slurp right

I think the above key mapping were the default from nvim-treesitter-sexp I'll check the lua/plugins/clojure.lua config, sounds like the alternate mapping config is not in the right place

I'm having a hell of a time understanding how to use lisp editing with this config and keep from destroying what I'm writing.

Have
(defn module [f] (let [data {:parent (.getParent f)}] data))

Execute
Return with cursor between the [f] and the (let

Expect
(defn module [f]
  (let [data {:parent (.getParent f)}] data)

Get
(defn module [f])
(let [data {:parent (.getParent f)}] data)

Move cursor to inside first form at ^
(defn mod^ule [f])
(let [data {:parent (.getParent f)}] data)

Think about what barf and slurp and left and right mean. 
"Um slurp... right?"

Type
>)

Get no edit, the cursor moves only
(defn module [f])
(let [data {:parent (.getParent f)}] data)^

and because paredit is aggressively "fixing" my keystrokes I can't just switch into editing characters and fix it into something that will run 😭

The way I'm reading the characters it would be >) move the end parenthesis forward to enclose <) move the end parenthesis backward to disgorge <( move the start parenthesis backward to enclose the form behind >( move the start parenthesis forward to disgorge the earliest form

I've also tried pasting things into the inside of parentheses and I just keep making things worse

Let me add btw that sometimes I'm also just typing something, fretting I'll have an editing disaster, and the plugin guesses exactly what I mean. So I can tell it's good, I'm just holding it so wrong that I can barely type

Sounds like you should comment the parinfer plugin, or set it to parents mode. Parinfer by default expects the user to manage the indentation and it doesn't sound like this is being done. Suggest only using the nvim-treesitter-sexp plugin from the clojure.lua config file. I am away for a few days so won't have much time to pick through the specific comments

Understood. I have partly started understanding how to work with it. It might be as simple as unlearning older styles of managing the cursor, because I started speeding up once I started just hitting return and typing and letting the algorithm catch up. Thanks for the configuration work you put in 🙏

FWIW, I personally have parinfer switched off

So far I've been enjoying the default mappings, and they don't seem to limit or conflict with anything I regularly use.

I did add the <leader>k for a while and it just seemed clunky to me, like k>) for slurping right

Thanks for the feedback, very useful. The <leader>k was a homage to the Lisp state in Emacs (Spacemacs), although I only use a few of those in Spacemacs now (usually just raise) I'll add nvim-treesitter-sexp package to the Astronvim Clojure pack, along with info on how to configure/disable plugins from the pack (disable a specific plugin should be a one additional line after importing the Clojure pack in the user config. Hopefully people enjoy using both plugins or only notice the one they use :)