why are tasks sometimes defined in a catalog and sometimes not? not in a catalog https://github.com/onyx-platform/onyx-template/blob/0.14.x/src/leiningen/new/onyx_app/src/onyx_app/jobs/basic.clj in catalog : http://www.onyxplatform.org/docs/user-guide/latest/#_catalog

is there a fundamental difference?

to add to @guillaume.carbonneau question, they are in a catalog in the learn-onyx workshop too

@guillaume.carbonneau If i recall the example your saying that isn’t in catalog is by having the base job threaded through the add-task calls building up a catalog

yeah, why is there 2 methods? is one preferred?

i believe the add-task does some validation and such. Been awhile