hyperfiddle

Dustin Getz (Hyperfiddle) 2025-12-18T13:17:15.420759Z

Question - as y'all know the electric compiler requires login to activate. Our Auth0 instance is currently configured to allow login by either Google or username-password database. It turns out about half of you chose to create a username-password instead of clicking the google button, which surprises me. My question: was this on purpose, or was it because you didn't see the google button? I ask because I still get occasional DMs from people confused about needing to create an account, so I intend to streamline this by removing the username-password option (which is a legacy mechanism anyway due to bad UX). If you have a strong objection to this, I'd like to hear it now!

oλv 2025-12-18T13:31:32.224839Z

Having to log in with Google would be mildly inconvenient for me as I rarely use a Google account :^)

thomas 2025-12-18T13:34:40.006739Z

I think I use the google method.... but not 100% certain.

bdbrodie 2025-12-18T14:05:11.612489Z

I've been migrating away from Google this month for privacy reasons, so loosing an alternative would be inconvenient. Perhaps Auth0 has support for passkeys as a future-oriented login method, might be less friction for new users?

Dustin Getz (Hyperfiddle) 2025-12-18T14:17:46.373519Z

@b.brodie would github work

💯 6
Dustin Getz (Hyperfiddle) 2025-12-18T14:19:57.226509Z

also are your companies moving away from google workspace (docs etc) as well? one of my assumptions is that virtually all commercial users, of all sizes, has google login (or microsoft for enterprise)

Dustin Getz (Hyperfiddle) 2025-12-18T14:20:54.870679Z

i will look into passkeys

bdbrodie 2025-12-18T14:47:32.872649Z

Agreed that Microsoft login is preferred for enterprise. Have to keep at least one Google Workspace around, for testing purposes. UX for passkeys has really improved the last few weeks, I'm hopeful it will go mainstream in 2026.

JAtkins 2025-12-18T17:59:29.052029Z

I have no strong opinion. However, I would generally like an alternative. I don't like the risk of XYZ big company kicking me off for some reason and then I lose access to my accounts. I've recently converted several SSO accounts to passkey or username + pw. I'm probably not concerned about this for Electric, since I can just ping yall in that remote eventuality.

grounded_sage 2025-12-25T16:42:39.548499Z

I prefer having the options. Generally use a poorly defined heuristic for when I choose to use another service provider or password for sign in. I have tended towards dev things I sign in using the GitHub sign in because if I don't have access to GitHub I won't be doing much dev work

Reut Sharabani 2025-12-20T19:40:02.415129Z

Is it possible to make the user/password less obvious? (click an extra link) This way you can see the ongoing trend. If people still use it - it's probably intentional. (personally I'd use google)

noonian 2025-12-19T15:44:14.815199Z

I did this intentionally. I prefer keeping my accounts separate rather than all linked to Google but it wouldn't bother me to switch methods

Vincent 2025-12-19T21:22:17.439619Z

What google button 🙂?

jdhollis 2025-12-19T22:50:32.524929Z

I don't like linking accounts because who knows what happens down the road.

jdhollis 2025-12-19T22:51:17.482459Z

Service dependencies 😛

jdhollis 2025-12-19T22:51:51.628459Z

I can control whether I have access to my email address/username (mostly).

braai engineer 2025-12-21T21:06:46.428979Z

plz keep custom email & password. I like to keep sovereign domain, and I don't want to give Google money.

braai engineer 2025-12-21T21:08:32.210229Z

@dustingetz when you say "remove username-password option" does that mean removing non-Google email? I assume not, but checking.

braai engineer 2025-12-21T21:09:35.340979Z

I prefer custom email & password for everything. Don't want to tie AuthN / identity to any 3rd party service like Github where possible. I only use GitHub to sign in where repos are relevant.